Heated Rivalry
Sullivan West Comes On Strong In Second Half To Defeat Tri-Valley In Season Opener; Non-League Tilt Is The Latest Chapter In A Competitive Rivalry; T-V’s Exner Electrifies; SW’s Borowski Scores A Trio Of TD’s
Sullivan West 21, Tri-Valley 14
By RICHARD A. ROSS
rross@sportsinsightsny.com (album of photos at sportsinsights.smugmug.com)
Compelling moments in a storied history: Sullivan West and Tri-Valley write the next chapter in their ongoing saga as the Bulldogs come back from a 14-7 halftime deficit with two more TD's from Kitt Borowski (He returned a kick off 70 yards in the first half for his first) to defeat the Bears. Pictured clockwise are game icons including Tri-Valley junior Cody Exner who ran for a TD and racked up 103 yards of rushing on 11 carries. Greg Swarthout hauls in a 39-yard strike from QB Joe Mickelson to give the Bears a 14-7 lead at the half. Sullivan West players exult in their victory and lower left, senior Kitt Borowski scores the second of his three TD's on the day on a seven-yard run which tied the score at 14-all. He scored again with just over six minutes remaining on a five-yard jaunt.
GRAHAMSVILLE, NY—Rivalry is an integral part of sports. When teams play each other year in and year out, not just in regular season outings but also in years where titles are at stake, that rivalry intensifies. Fans feed on those rivalries be they zealots of professional, college or high school sports. Invariably, no matter what the weather, crowds come out in droves to bear witness to the games that have historical juice to them.
Whenever Sullivan West and Tri-Valley meet on the gridiron, it is bound to be just such an occasion.
Though they now inhabit different divisions in Section Nine’s Class C making last year’s game and this year’s encounter non-league frays, the fervor displayed by the teams and their supportive communities has not abated.
Last year’s game played at Sullivan West’s Homecoming may have been one whose outcome had no impact on the playoff bound Bears nor the playoff-missing Bulldogs, but make no mistake about it, Tri-Valley’s 26-20 win stung the Bulldogs nonetheless. It was the tenth gridiron encounter of the two schools and it brought Tri-Valley closer in the series which Sullivan West now led 6-4.
Ever since 2005 when the Bulldogs dropped down into Tri-Valley’s realm of Class C, the two schools have staged annual epic battles that have included meeting four times in post season play, three of them for the Section Nine Class C title and once in a semifinal tilt.
In addition the schools vied for Division titles up until last year when the realignment in the OCIAA placed them in different divisions. Check out the history section below for details on which team won what over their relatively short but heated rivalry.
Off to the races: Tri-Valley's Cody Exner gallops 40 yards for the first score of the game as the Bears capitalized on a rare fumble by Sullivan West's Thomas Mootz. to gain possession of the ball during the Westies first offensive series.
This year’s fray was unique in that it was the first time the teams opened their seasons facing each other. Normally their encounters are late-season occurrences often greatly anticipated and circled on calendars as impending show downs.
Needless to say each team wanted to win its opener, while fully understanding that the games that determine their postseason afterlife will be their league encounters.
Gone from Tri-Valley is the outstanding Peter DiMilia whose fiery play on both sides of the ball exerted a huge impact on the games over the past several years.
Similarly, Sullivan West QB Ryan Alsdorf also graduated, but as is the case with rival teams, others step forward to assume the mantle. Calling signals for the Bears is senior Joe Mickelson who moved from his effective capacity as a running back to hopefully guide the Bears back to the playoffs. Last year T-V lost to Burke 46-25 in the Class C semifinals.
For the Westies, another veteran running back E.J. Franskevicz moves to take over the reins. Both Franskevicz and Mickelson are key defensive backs as well.
By day’s end it would be clear that several other players would make their presence felt including Tri-Valley junior running back Cody Exner whose electrifying speed produced one touchdown and nearly another were it not for a game-saving tackle by Sullivan West’s Sawyer Erlwein. Exner would carry the ball 11 times for 103 yards and it took the Bulldogs most of the game to figure out a way to contain him.
For the Bulldogs, this game would be the coming out party for senior running back Kitt Borowski who made his mark last year principally as a receiver. Borowski scored all three of Sullivan West’s TD’s. His day began with an auspicious 70-yard kickoff return to the house, an emphatic answer to Exner’s 40-yard TD gallop on a pitch from Mickelson that had come earlier on the Bears’ second series of the game.
Good teams capitalize on their opponents’ mistakes and that first scoring drive by T-V was marshaled following a rare fumble by Sullivan West’s hard-nosed running back Thomas Mootz. Anthony Beale’s PAT had given the Bears a brief 7-0 lead before Borowski took the ensuing kickoff 70 yards to the house. Erlwein’s PAT knotted the game at seven all with 8:30 remaining in the first quarter.
The go-ahead score: Sullivan West's Kitt Borowski rumbles in from five yards out with just over six minutes left to play as Jared Meola helps to clear the way.
Borowski’s return aside, Sullivan West looked out of sync most of the first half. Its spread offense, now in its third year of deployment appeared to offer little mystique as Tri-Valley defenders led by the seemingly omnipresent senior Troy Rossi and other swarming Bears stifled the Bulldogs’ running game and harried QB Franskevicz. Trying to take advantage of the surging Bears vanguard, Franskevicz tossed a couple of screen passes that might have gone for big yardage but he failed to complete them.
Meanwhile Mickelson gave Tri-Valley the lead back with 8:24 remaining in the second quarter with a 39-yard strike to senior wide out Greg Swarthout. Beale was perfect again and the Bears were able to withstand a late interception by Jared Meola to take a 14-7 lead into halftime.
The intense heat was bound to take its toll on players though officials called time outs to allow for water respites accordingly over the course of the day. As the game wore on in the second half, it appeared that Tri-Valley was affected more.
Missing a couple of players including senior running back Tyler Lopez who had sustained a blow to the head and was suffering from some heat exhaustion as well, the Bears began to wear down and the Bulldogs’ ground game inspired by a strong halftime pep talk suddenly was making headway with big runs.
Sullivan West received to start the second half but went three and out. Once again Tri-Valley was on the march even making gains by recovering its own fumble as Exner rumbled 13 yards after picking up a loose ball. But an interception snagged by Erlwein halted the drive at the SW 33. By day’s end Mickelson would be picked off three times.
Enlivened by the opportunity, the Bulldogs showed their first real signs of life as Thomas Mootz, Franskevicz, Jared Meola and Borowski kept the chains moving. Borowski capped off the drive with a seven-yard TD run with 1:27 left in the third quarter and Erlwein’s PAT knotted the game at 14-all.
Drama was far from over however as T-V Coach John Rusin continued to exhort his players to give their all. Rusin in a great motivator in addition to being a fine gridiron guru. Despite the fact that his team is young and not as deep as prior years, he will get every ounce of their effort for 48 minutes each and every week.
Exner and Mickelson ran the ball well and Tri-Valley began the fourth quarter in possession of the pigskin. The drive halted with a fourth and seven at the Sullivan West 20, well within striking distance of the talented Beale, whose soccer experience has made him a potent weapon as a kicker. In practice I watched him make kick after kick, but as Rusin would later point out, he has been untested in live game action when it came to field goals.
In a league of their own: Tri-Valley's talented cheerleaders rev up the crowd at halftime.
Beale’s potential go-ahead kick sailed wide left and the Dawgs took over at the 20 with 9:58 remaining in the game. Mootz ripped off a big 24-yard run out to the Westies’ 44. Franksevicz picked up another first down. Borowski’s run to the T-V 12 was called back on a block in the back penalty but the Dawgs would prove undaunted.
Franskevicz ran for another first down. By day’s end he’d have carried the rock 12 times for 61 yards and much of that was coming when it mattered the most. With 6:08 remaining in the game, Borowski broke free for an eight-yard strike and Erlwein punctuated that with a PAT to give the Dawgs their first lead of the day, 21-14.
Exner nearly returned the ensuing kickoff to the house but a diving Erlwein just managed to trip him up. It was the most impressive of Erlwein’s 12 tackles on the day. That said, here were the Bears at the Sullivan West 29 with 5:07 remaining.
Historically, late game heroics have played a big part in the storied rivalry. In 2007 in a game story entitled “The Line of Demarcation,” Tri-Valley withstood four Sullivan West attempts in the red zone to hold on to a 13-7 Division clinching win. In 2005 James Connelly gave the Bears a 20-17 OT win with his timely field goal.
So here we were again late in a game between these two contentious squads with the game on the line. If the Bears could score, they’d undoubtedly try for a two-point conversion to win the game and with Exner and company looming, that was a distinct possibility.
Sullivan West’s defense stiffened and Tri-Valley incurred a holding penalty to boot. The issue of flags flying and then being picked up had already been a side story to this encounter. Those reversals had favored Sullivan West and Rusin hoped one would go his way.
It didn’t.
Mickelson completed a pass to Jesus Lozada but still faced a fourth and 3 at the 20. Mickelson dropped back to pass but he was sacked by Sullivan West senior defensive end Andrew Parsons. The Bulldogs took over on downs but failed to keep possession. Facing a fourth and two, Coach Ron Bauer called for a punt which gave the Bears another shot with 2:07 remaining as they started from their own 48 after Sullivan West had to re-punt the ball following an illegal formation.
Rusin rallied his troops and called for an inspired two-minute drill. Naturally the ball was going to Exner and Sullivan West knew it. Erlwein snared him again leading to a third and three. Following two incomplete pass attempts, the Bulldogs got the ball back and were able to run out the clock for their uplifting victory.
Not this time: Sullivan West's E.J. Franskevicz and Sawyer Erlwein close in on Cody Exner in Tri-Valley's final series that gave the Bulldogs the ball back and the ability to run out the clock.
For their part, the Bears knew how close they had come to an inspiring home win over their arch-rivals. If both teams make it to the playoffs, they may meet again for what will then be their 12th encounter in their historic rivalry. You can bet if that happens that the memories from this game will still be fresh.
As Promised..The History Channel
2005 Section Nine Championship SW 34, T-V7 ; Division IV Title Game T-V 20, SW 17 OT
2006 Section Nine Championship SW 48, T-V 27; Division IV Title Game SW 21, T-V 7
2007 Section Nine Championship T-V 18, SW 7; Division IV Title Game TV 13, SW 7
2008 Section Nine Semi Finals (Hallow Win Game) SW 46, T-V 6
2009 Regular Season non-league SW 29, T-V 19
2010 Regular Season non-league TV 26, SW 20
2011 Regular Season non-league SW 21, TV 14
Sullivan West leads the series 7-4.
Franskevicz and his teammates took a moment to comment on the game as they exited the field . Franksevicz noted, “It was a tough game. We were playing in the heat. I think we really pulled it out in the second half. We came out to play. We played like we know how to play.” Asked about what was said at halftime, Borowski noted, “We needed to show the will to win and to have the heart.”
Rusin was exceptionally proud of his team. Asked about the heat as a factor, he noted, “not making any excuses here, Sullivan West leaned on us enough. We don’t have a lot of depth. We’ve got a lot of young guys with a lot of heart but not much experience. They will be excellent players but our core group is not very deep right now,” he added.
“We had a few guys banged up here and there and that affects two or three positions. Again, no excuses, Sullivan West did a great job. They stuck with their game plan. They were bigger than us physically. “
Rusin extolled the play of Exner.”I’m not a big fan of getting tendencies with play calling but when you’ve got one kid on the field whose a game-breaker and who has legs at a given point of time…so we went to the same play a couple of times. I’m sure SW was ready for it but you hope to catch lightning in a bottle.”
“Rossi is the energetic leader. He always has a bounce in his step. He lives for football. He was all over the field today and he’s been studying a lot of film trying to perfect what he has to do.”
Until We Meet Again....Sullivan West and Tri-Valley plays extend the hand or respect towards each other. Both squads know the rivalry is far from over.
This was a big game for us. We had a lot of kids we hoped would come out this year who didn’t. We have a hard-working core group and came out of camp with a very positive feeling. We knew numbers could be an issue for us. We were hoping to put a couple of scores on the board early and play with a little bit of lead. But you have to tip your hat to Sullivan West. They stuck with their plan and they wore us down as the game went on.”
Asked about Beale’s missed field goal attempt as a potential shift in momentum, Rusin was quick to affirm his kicker’s ability. “When you have a kid who can hit them you go with it. He had plenty of distance. We just haven’t given him that much work in live situations. I think he did everything right. Sometimes it just doesn’t go your way. I wouldn’t hesitate one iota to use him again in that same spot. He knows how to kick the ball.”
Tri-Valley has three night games on the road in the coming weeks starting with their first league match up against Pine Plains, then non-league frays against Chester and Eldred. Rusin and his valiant Bears will put this game quickly in the rearview mirror and turn their attention towards beating the Bombers.
Bauer noted, “We got more focused in the second half and I think our conditioning paid off as well. The heat was tough today. We started to block a little better and hit the holes, “ he added. “We wanted to do well in our season opener. The kids were up and they wanted to play good ball. In the first half we played good at times but we weren’t as focused.”
Sullivan West hosts Chester under the lights on September 9 in a non-league tilt.
Stat line: Sullivan West Rushing Total 42/151; Borowski 6/68 with three TD’s; Franskevicz 12/61; Mootz 10/58
Defense: Erlwein 12 tackles and an interception
Tri-Valley Rushing: Total 36/183; Exner 11/103 and a 40-yard TD; Mickelson 4/17; Aric Boyes 5/12; Brendan Tierney 4/25/ Tyler Lopez 2/26.
Passing: Mickelson 3/10 with a 39-yard TD to Greg Swarthout. Swartout 1/1/4
Receiving Swartout 1/1/39 yard TD; Exner 2/30; Jesus Lozada 1/4
Sullivan West is 1-0; Tri-Valley is 0-1
For an album of photos visit sportsinsights.smugmug.com
